Mobile locksmithPensacola to Panama City Estimate agreed before work starts Typically there in 15–20 min Open 24/7 (850) 920-7113 Text us
Illustration: a lock cylinder taken apart with its pins in a tray, next to a new boxed deadbolt

Should you rekey a lock or buy a new one?

(850) 920-7113

Rekeying changes which key opens the lock. Replacing changes the lock itself. After a move or a lost key, rekeying is often all you need.

THE SHORT ANSWER

The two jobs sound similar and get mixed up all the time. Rekeying keeps your hardware and changes the key. Replacing swaps the hardware.

QUICK ANSWER

Rekey when the lock works fine and you just want the old keys to stop working, for example after moving in. Replace it when it is damaged, sticks, or you want a different type of lock. Call (850) 920-7113 and we can quote both.

Published: · Updated: · By the Best Value Locksmith team

Is rekeying cheaper than replacing a lock?

Rekeying usually costs less than replacing a lock, because the hardware stays and only the pins inside the cylinder change. The difference grows with the number of doors, since several locks can be set to one key in a single visit. Replacement costs more, but it is the right call for damaged, worn or outdated hardware. Best Value Locksmith quotes both before any work starts. Rekeying also lets you key several doors alike, so one key opens the front, back and garage-entry locks when they share a keyway. Replacing makes sense when a lock grinds, the bolt drags, or you want a keypad or smart lock instead. After a move, many owners do both: a smart lock on the main door and the remaining locks rekeyed.

STEP 01

When rekeying makes sense

You just moved in, a key went missing, or someone who had one no longer should. If the lock still works smoothly, rekeying fixes the access problem. Ask whether your other doors can be set to the same key while we are there.

STEP 02

When a new lock makes sense

The lock is damaged, it grinds or sticks, or you want something different, like a keypad. Upgrading to a smart lock is its own decision, separate from just changing who has a key.

STEP 03

Compare the whole job

Ask how many locks are included, how many keys you get, and whether parts, labor and the service call are in the estimate. Two quotes are only comparable when they cover the same work.

STEP 04

A new-home checklist

Count every exterior lock: front, back and side doors, the door from the garage, sliding door locks and any gate. Add the garage keypad code, the mailbox lock and any smart lock codes or app accounts the previous owner set up. Each one is a way in that old keys or codes may still open.

STEP 05

One key for the whole house

Locks that take the same keyway can be rekeyed to one key, so a single key opens every exterior door. Bring every key you were given, and we tell you which locks can share one and which would need a new cylinder.

Was this guide helpful?

GOOD QUESTIONS. STRAIGHT ANSWERS.

More questions about rekeying

Can’t find your answer? Call or text and tell us what’s going on.

Yes, but it usually takes a locksmith. Do-it-yourself kits and SmartKey resets rely on a working key, while a locksmith can rekey the lock without one after checking you are allowed to change it. Home rekeying with Best Value Locksmith starts from $45 per cylinder. Have photo ID and proof of address ready when the technician arrives.

The cylinder comes out of the lock, the old pins are removed, and new pins are set to match a new key, so the old keys stop working while the hardware stays on the door. It takes the right tools, pin kits and either the working key or a way to remove the cylinder, which is why most owners have a locksmith do it. Tell us how many locks there are and which brands. Call (850) 920-7113 to book.

Every exterior door lock, the door from the garage into the house and any side or back gates, plus the mailbox if it has a lock. Change the garage keypad code and reset any smart locks or their app accounts. If you want one key for everything, mention it, since compatible locks can be keyed alike in the same visit. Call (850) 920-7113 with the number of doors.

Rekey if you are happy with keyed locks and only need the old keys to stop working. Switch to a smart lock if you want codes for guests, cleaners or family, or entry from your phone. Many owners do both: a smart lock on the front door, with the other doors rekeyed to match its backup key where the keyway allows. Call (850) 920-7113 to plan it.
A SOLUTION STARTS WITH A CONVERSATION

Need a hand with a lock or key?

Call (850) 920-7113 and tell us what happened and where you are. We confirm availability and the estimate before any work begins.

Call now(850) 920-7113Text